How to Disagree Agreeably

by Rebecca Morgan, CSP, CMC on August 16, 2017

  • Your new co-worker is proposing a project that was tried before she arrived and failed.
  • Your boss suggests a direction you think will be a disaster.
  • Your lunch-mate is sharing a “fact” you know has been debunked.

Situations like these are commonplace. Someone says something you either know to be wrong or with which you disagree. How you respond determines how you will be perceived by them and others present, as well as how receptive they will be to hearing your point of view.

What you say next and how you say it set the tone.

If you blurt, “We tried that and it failed,” “That’s not a good idea,” “That’s just not true,” “That is wrong,” or “You’re ill-informed,” or worse, “That’s a lie,” you have lost the argument. Even if what you say is more rational, proven and accepted by experts.

So what can you say that will allow (at least for a while) a sane discussion instead of a shouting match? How do you start?

  • First, be especially mindful of your tone of voice. The right words can sound wrong if there is irritation in your voice. You want to sound calm, open and interested.
  • Clarify anything that seems illogical to you. Do your best TV detective Columbo imitation. Detective Columbo used self-degradation to get his suspect to flesh out their reasoning and then they’d often stumble when he asked simple questions. You don’t want to then yell, “Gotcha,” as no one respects a gloater. Avoid starting with “why” as it can sound confrontational.

“I may be having a brain burp, but I’m not seeing how x leads to y. Can you help me understand your thinking that got you to that conclusion?”
“I hear your idea and I’m not seeing how it will work out the way you describe. Can we go back to where you said ….?”
“I tracked your thinking up to x point. Then I lost you as I don’t see how you got to the next step. What am I missing?”
“Help me understand how we’d make sure to avoid…”
“I’m guessing you have a plan to ensure we’d not have x happen. Can you help me understand that plan?”

  • Point out where you agree.

“I agree with your point about… ”
“You make a good case for …”
“Your point on x is valid.”

  • Validate that you understand their point of view. Acknowledging doesn’t mean you agree.

“I can see how that could make sense.”
“I understand your perspective.”
“I can see how that could seem like a good solution.”
“I know what you’re saying could solve some of what we’re trying to accomplish.”

  • Introduce your doubts as a professional journalist would. They probe for deeper understanding without pushing back as themselves, but asking how others might have trouble understanding.

“What would you say to others who would doubt that x will result in y?”
“Some people might wonder how you came to that conclusion. How would you explain it to them?”

  • Introduce your opinion diplomatically.

“While I agree with x, y and z, here’s where we diverge…”
“I’d like to share a different perspective.”
“Let me offer another option.”
“I’d like to present an opposite point of view so we are sure to explore various opinions.”

  • Avoid, at all costs, personally disparaging the other. Do not say something like,

“With your (profession, education level, university, state, country, IQ, gender) you would not have full information.”
“That makes no sense.”
“That’s just stupid.”
“You people (e.g., HR folks, engineers, women, men, Gen Xers, Boomers) all think alike.”

  • If the other person denigrates you, you can:

Ignore the comment and stay on the topic.
Say, “That has no bearing on this discussion. Let’s stay focused on the topic.”
“That was out of line. I’d appreciate your staying professional and focus on the ideas being shared.”

Can you avoid all confrontational conversations? Of course not. Some people are so entrenched in their way of thinking they are offended that anyone would not see they are right. Your job is to avoid being one of them. 🙂

Instead, you’ll have a more productive conversation if you stay calm and respectful, even if the other person doesn’t. If the conversation begins to degenerate, don’t get sucked down with it.

Try some of these ideas when you’re with a friend, stating first that you want to try some new skills and you need a practice partner. Let him/her in on what you’re doing and want to practice. Then mutually agree on a topic to disagree on — ideally adopting a mock stance on the issue. Afterwards, discuss what worked, how you both felt at various times in the discussion, and what you could do differently to be more effective next time.

When you are able to learn to disagree agreeably, without getting upset, you will be open to at least understanding a different perspective, even if you don’t agree with it. And in many cases, you’ll jointly come up with an better solution than either of you would have thought of on your own.

{ 5 comments… read them below or add one }

Ambrosehat July 11, 2019 at 3:47 am

Dating sites for sex:

Popular tags: hook up utilities saskatoon, cancer and scorpio dating, millionaire dating service new york, dating sites in ireland reviews, punk rock hook up, 18-25 speed dating, 16 year old dating, dating a man 40 years older, th350 vacuum modulator hook up, duggar dating rules list, how do i delete uniform dating account, free dating sites no credit card, free dating website aus, was ist ein matchmaking spiel, chicago jewish dating, senior dating apps, best way to describe yourself on dating website, free indian dating site malaysia, star trek online dating, 4 bases of dating, speed dating mustang prank, free online dating in arizona, dating agency cyrano sub thai, free online asian dating services, single parents dating online, free dating chat room sites, why dating a sorority girl is better, my soul mate dating site, boundaries in dating john townsend, lee evans speed dating youtube, dating site fishinthesea, online christian dating sites free, waje dating mi, glasgow dating online, dating experiences, coffee dating agency, tattoo artist dating site, utro dating, ukraine dating agencies, words to describe myself for dating site, dating in abuja nigeria, free dating websites in bucks, what are good dating apps for the iphone, free dating site christian, dating espana, 22 year old dating 17, is chilli dating lasse, dating rules from my future self streaming vk, dating barrie ontario, babysit dating versailles 2013, how to write a good profile for a dating site, ashley benson dating chord overstreet, matchmaking horoscope matching, dating in bismarck nd, online hook up australia, brenda dating site reviews, safe dating verification login, help writing a dating profile examples, executive dating service toronto, laws on dating a minor in arizona, free online dating in malawi, dating sites slogans, dating pharmacy school, best place to hook up in atlanta, dating dance show nbc, online dating sites for over 40, dating sites cornwall ont, dating agencies cairns, geek dating websites, a good dating name, zen habits dating, dating alpha female, 100 free dating sites nz, mission dating meetic, christian dating not a virgin, best cities for interracial dating 2015, re dating ex girlfriend, dating sites for cubs fans, online dating for graduate students, lee hong ki dating celebrity, how to talk to a woman online dating, dating sites cornwall uk, dark souls arena matchmaking, platonic love dating, pisces dating gemini, dating age laws in pa, rules for teenage dating, korean girl dating mexican guy, free rockford dating, marriage not dating ep 12, best dating sites for open relationships, virginia dating sites, how to start a dating website online, aarp dating boot camp, weird russian dating site pictures, online dating buzz, free dating site ahmedabad, rtl dating programma, gay dating site in south africa, chatting dating site, senior dating iowa, i am dating two friends, online dating sites reviews australia, are austin and ally dating in real life, who is lil scrappy dating now 2013, dating amputee ladies, carbon dating artifacts, do cheerleaders dating football players, free dating sites in mozambique, muslim dating other religions, dating site to meet firemen, is relative dating based on radioactive decay, best dating site north wales, dindigul dating site, top lesbian dating apps 2015, divorced christian dating sites, sugar mummy dating in usa, consumer reports online dating sites, 24 year old dating 17 year old illegal, middle earth dating site, asian dating agency sydney, black cafe dating site, online dating site for animal lovers, speed dating billings mt, creative online dating usernames, marriage not dating sinopsis ep 1, sinopsis dating cyrano agency ep 9, is a 15 year old dating a 13 year old weird, lesbian dating websites free, free dating on online, beauty online dating site, double your dating download, who is justin bieber dating january 2015, absolute dating science, speed dating york pa, who’s dating who chris evans, jerry trainor dating history, anchorage dating sites, love drunk dating bedford, dating sms text messages, best free dating app for android india, job dating sncf, aoa seolhyun dating, girl dating sites, gay dating chennai, pof dating website uk, dating comparison site, the world’s largest dating site, free online buddhist dating, dating sites nsw australia, indian online dating sites free, brisbane single parent dating site, pure filipina online dating, orlando bloom dating kate beckinsale, are you interested free dating site, free dating sites comparisons, photo dating profile, dating service open relationship, most popular dating site 2014, gay dating sites popular, free online dating in mn, free online dating over 45, big church dating site, dating successful men, radioactive dating of rocks, list of free mobile dating sites, is iballisticsquid dating anyone, best polish dating site, expats dating in dubai, free online dating in dallas tx, online dating st catharines, speed dating for black professionals in london, 45 year old man dating a 30 year old woman, ang dating daan religious practices, dark souls prepare to die online matchmaking, top matchmaking rating dota 2, online dating swapping numbers, po fish dating site, free dating for iphone, kk girl dating, hook up control valve, muslim speed dating events leeds, africa online dating sites, dating tall, crystal castles courtship dating meaning, new bedford single dating, dating asian australian, alycia bellamy dating, rugby league dating, online dating sites top 10, melbourne dating app, last of us matchmaking unfair, dating logo png, san diego speed dating events, free dating aberdeen, unicorn dating matrix, online dating mandurah, bahai dating sites, radiocarbon dating and archaeology, jade dating in the dark uk, mmr matchmaking, recent online free dating sites, burley hook up, dating your barista, how would a paleontologist use relative dating techniques to determine the age of a fossil, sarah beeny dating site, dating site lulu, dating text messaging rules, netherlands dating customs, dating kramer guitars, free dating site vadodara, when is the best time to join an online dating site, straight guys dating transgender, navi mumbai dating, best age to start dating christian, recovery from dating a sociopath, tulare dating, zoosk online dating login, free dating sites dayton ohio, dating alpha male personality, carbon dating and radioactive dating, dating friends ex, tips speed dating questions, template for a dating profile, dating and sexuality in adolescence, maker of chinese dating app momo files for u.s. ipo, gay dating darlington, need dating help, is carbon dating relative or absolute, gay bear speed dating, is dating a family friend bad, internet dating in gauteng, bad dating profiles examples, lds dating non members, raya dating site, indian man dating white girl, dating now asya fanatikleri, dating kharkov, joshua harris i kissed dating goodbye wikipedia, how to talk to someone on online dating, christian dating in college, online dating gold coast, good taglines for a dating site, best dating website for one night stands, interracial dating sites in the uk, do aria and mr fitz dating in real life, online dating in coimbatore, stonehenge dating methods, dating management app, dating ben 10, dating free chatting, what to write in first message on dating site, online dating baggage reclaim

herman December 9, 2019 at 1:52 am

Hello and welcome to my website . I’m Herman.
I have always dreamed of being a writer but never dreamed I’d make a career of it. In college, though, I assisted a fellow student who needed help. She could not stop telling me how well I had done. Word got around and someone asked me for writing help just a week later. This time they would pay me for my work.
During the summer, I started doing research papers for students at the local college. It helped me have fun that summer and even funded some of my college tuition. Today, I still offer my writing services to students.

Writing Specialist – Herman – Do my homework 123 Confederation

evamccarthy December 26, 2019 at 2:07 am

Hello everyone , I’m Eva.
Welcome to my homepage . I started writing in middle school after a creative writing assignment for my English teacher. I did creative writing for almost a year before I thought about doing something else.
I had always loved doing research assignments because I’m passionate about learning. When you combine writing ability with a love of learning, dissertation writing only makes sense as a job.
I’m passionate about aiding the students of the future in their school career. When they don’t like their assignment , I am there to help.

Eva – Academic Writing Help – Band

jody January 8, 2020 at 1:55 am

Hello ,
I’m Jody Read.
If you’ve ever been too tired and couldn’t finish a research assignment , then you’ve come to the right place. I assist students in all areas of the writing steps . I can also write the essay from start to finish.
My career as a professional writer started early in college . After learning that I was very capable in the field of academic writing, I decided to take it up as a profession.

Skilled Academic Writer- Jody Read- Corps

kelsie January 13, 2020 at 1:33 am

Welcome everyone ! I’m Kelsie Davenport.
Even though I jokingly credit my mother for my writing talent, I know that it is a ability I have fostered from childhood. Though my aunt is a writer, I also started out young.
I’ve always had a way with words, according to my favorite educator. I was always so excited in science when we had to do a research paper .
Now, I help current students achieve the grades that have always come easily to me. It is my way of giving back to schools because I understand the troubles they must overcome to graduate.

Kelsie Davenport – Professional Writer – Team

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: